ANDREW HILL — Point of Departure (review)

ANDREW HILL — Point of Departure album cover Album · 1964 · Post Bop Buy this album from MMA partners
3/5 ·
Sean Trane
When asking fans about a favourite early work of Andrew Hill, the present PoD will probably get many mentions, if not more than all the other albums combined. While the album is a good progression on Black Fire, I’ve often thought that the present’s title might be a bit misleading, despite some undeniable progress in terms of groundbreaking-ness, but let’s face it, it’s all very relative when comparing to Trane, Ornette or Cecil. Using most of the line-up from the BF album, but replacing Haynes by Tony Williams and adding the great Eric Dolphy, PoD is generally highly regarded and often pointed-out as Hill’s chef d’oeuvre, but this writer begs to differ.

Indeed, Dolphy’s presence on the present album does seem to give it an “avant-garde” edge, but if you listen to the other four partakers, you won’t find all that much to reinforce that “edge”, with all due respect to Tony, Andrew, Richard & Joe. I want for exhibit A the opening 12-mins aptly-titled Refuge (from the garde’s avant). To these ears, PoD’s jazz sounds rather standard, once past Dolphy’s modern and often slightly dissonant sax and scratching a bit deeper. OK, yours truly is not a musician, so he can’t dissect the chord and time signatures structures, but to these somewhat-experimented ears (over two decades of jazz explorations), we’re not dealing with anything close to avant-garde in the semantic meaning (freeform), but more like a post-bop album which found itself lumped in the wrong category by inexact writers that lacked the historical insight and the necessary retrospective sense (I wouldn’t claim I’d have done it better either). To these ears, only the 9-mins+ Spectrum’s middle section and its predecessor New Monastery seem to stick out as a real departure, including Dolphy’s flute and later on clarinet’s squeakings and squealings, and Flight 19 getting a short experimental flight, with Dobham’s trumpet taking the lead pilot role. The closing Dedication opens on some Spanish-sounding trumpet, and Dolphy’s bass clarinet adds some colours but in the end result, it sounds like they’re late one revolution.

If I may sound a bit harsh in my opening comments, PoD remains a fine album and it most certainly is one for AH in his discography but let’s face it, this is not essential listening (despite Williams, Henderson and Dolphy’s presence) to me, although it’s definitely worth the detour and knowing what the present album is all about. Prefer Compulsion’s 5 “!” to this Departure.

Share this review
more

Review Comments

Post a public comment below | Send private message to the reviewer
Please login to post a shout
No shouts posted yet. Be the first member to do so above!

Review Index

Member Zone

Username:
Password:
Stay signed in

Jazz Subgenres

Artists Alpha-index

JMA TOP 5 Jazz ALBUMS

Rating by members, ranked by custom algorithm
Albums with 30 ratings and more
A Love Supreme Post Bop
JOHN COLTRANE
Buy this album from our partners
Kind of Blue Cool Jazz
MILES DAVIS
Buy this album from our partners
The Black Saint and the Sinner Lady Progressive Big Band
CHARLES MINGUS
Buy this album from our partners
Blue Train Hard Bop
JOHN COLTRANE
Buy this album from our partners
My Favorite Things Hard Bop
JOHN COLTRANE
Buy this album from our partners

New Jazz Artists

New Jazz Releases

6 Eclectic Fusion
KROKOFANT
Buy this album from MMA partners
Spring In Stockholm Live At Konserthuset, 1959 Cool Jazz
GERRY MULLIGAN
Buy this album from MMA partners
Mikolaj Trzaska, Ingebrigt Haker Flaten, Paal Nilssen-Love : The Last Temple vol.3 Avant-Garde Jazz
MIKOŁAJ TRZASKA
Buy this album from MMA partners
Mikolaj Trzaska, Ingebrigt Haker Flaten, Paal Nilssen-Love : The Last Temple, Vol.1 Avant-Garde Jazz
MIKOŁAJ TRZASKA
Buy this album from MMA partners
Mikołaj Trzaska / Ingebrigt Håker Flaten / Paal Nilssen-Love : The Last Temple Vol.2 Avant-Garde Jazz
MIKOŁAJ TRZASKA
Buy this album from MMA partners
More new releases

New Jazz Online Videos

FASCINATING RHYTHM - The Amazing Keystone Big Band feat. Neima Naouri
THE AMAZING KEYSTONE BIG BAND
snobb· 1 day ago
Alicante
RENAUD GARCIA-FONS
js· 1 day ago
She's Forty with Me
WILTON CRAWLEY
js· 1 day ago
Tall Tillie's Too Tight
WILTON CRAWLEY
js· 1 day ago
Rhoda Scott Ladies and Gentlemen - special guest : David Linx
RHODA SCOTT
snobb· 1 day ago
More videos

New JMA Jazz Forum Topics

More in the forums

New Site interactions

More...

Latest Jazz News

members-submitted

More in the forums

Social Media

Follow us
Follow us on Twitter Become a Facebook fan RSS Feed